Various Explanations of the
Undue Burden Test
1) The undue burden test transforms the nature of the right
from an unqualified
fundamental right to a qualified fundamental right. Instead of a
woman’s right to choose whether or not to terminate a pregnancy (the
right in Roe), there is now a woman’s right to be free of undue burdens
imposed by the state in choosing whether or not to terminate a
pregnancy (the right in Casey); or
2) The undue burden test reduces the level of scrutiny from
strict scrutiny to
intermediate scrutiny so the state has more state interests that meet
the test and more available means to accomplish its interests; or
3) The undue burden test operates as a sorting mechanism that
divides abortion regulations into two categories: those that impose
less than an undue burden and those that impose an undue burden. If the
abortion restriction imposes less than an undue burden, it will
be upheld as long as it has a rational basis (minimum scrutiny); if it
imposes an undue
burden, it will only be upheld if it is a least restrictive
means to achieve a compelling end (strict scrutiny).